Sure, here are the relevant parts from each villager. Remember, these are rumors...
Jasper Crumb
Sailor was using black magic to try to get married with Abigail. Abigail (Bride) finally married Mr. Rackham (Officer) instead of the poor Sailor.
Maitre d'
Abigail's (Bride) fiance was the Sailor. After she found something terrible at the Caribbean with the Officer, she abandoned her fiance for the Offficer.
Ned Kipps
Mr. Rackham (Officer) was in love with the Bride and tried to save the Bride from the Sailor's voodoo. Mr. Rackham gave Ned his first job on the island.
Evelyn Stocker
Bellemore Trading Company was losing revenue. Bellemore persuaded Mr Rackham to marry Abigail. They then hired the Sailor to seduce the Bride for a complicated plan, that would result the Officer handing the Manor the the company, while the Sailor and the Bride would run away together.
Edgar Kettle
Three bothers went missing and Abigail was behind it. Abigail used the Sailor to bump off her brothers and went for the Officer after that.