Dealing with the Gamer is one way to get her away from the arcade machine.
Perhaps she'd like a gift.
Have you found anything that would suit a nerdy collector?
Look in the Alleyway, behind Ye Olde Coocoo.
You'll first need to deal with the locked gate.
If you use the spacebar to find all of the hotspots, you're sure to pick it up.
Give the Profit Pet Plushie to the Gamer.
The other is to deal with the Ishmoby Whale.