This achievement will unlock with natural story progression.
What do I need to do?
Add something poisonous to pastry, then have the cook eat it.
How do I do that?
Getting something poisonous takes a while; you should follow these hints after winning the archery duel.
What do I do with this?
Open the box and bring the grimoire to the witch for a poisoned apple. Now you just need to mix it into some pastry.
Where will I find pastry?
You're supposed to be the baker's assistant, remember? There was more in the workshop than just a trapdoor and syringe.
Help me out.
Add the apple to the bowl of dough on the table, then ring the bell to summon the baker. You'll get the achievement when he turns a funny shade of green.
Achievement help
This is the guide for "A classic that never fails." achievement in The Legend of Skye. At Nice Game Hints you get hints even on the achievements. Click the big button below to get your first hint on getting this achievement.
Hi! I have written video game guides since 2018. Any money I make here will go towards improving my equipment so I can make the things you enjoy even better (and faster!)