When the footlocker opens --

-- look at the inside of the lid to find a piece of paper stuck to the inside lid. You've been finding pieces of paper all over the place that look like this, and if you look closely at the paper on the lid, they'll all appear in a row to the right of the taped in piece. It's obvious that you need to place the pieces here, but how? Read to the end of this hint for a screenshot of the final picture.

There are five collections of paper pieces to find, and you can wait till you get them all to start if you want, or you can start putting them together now if you're rather.

The trick to putting the pieces in place is that the pieces overlap. You might have three different pieces of paper that all show the corner of one item in the finished picture.

The final picture has one large central image, surrounded for four smaller images.

The central image is a star, and the smaller images are flowers. The flowers all have the stem in the center and the flower on the outside.

If you're having trouble getting the pieces to fit together, here's what the final will look like:

When you assemble the picture, Nancy says she's seen that same image in the lighthouse. So it's off in the dinghy again.